Friday, May 14, 2010

Point - Counterpoint with Rohr

"Sara Ruddick in her book Maternal Thinking: Toward a Politics of Peace speaks of the attentive love of a mother. In summary, Ruddick says mothers are characterized by attentive love. They have to keep watching this new life; they have to keep listening and adjusting to the needs of the child. It is necessary to recognize a new agenda with the growth of the child. If the mother cannot transform herself into attentive love, she quite simply cannot be a mother. She has to learn early on that life is about change, not about theological absolutes. All growth is about changing and adjusting to what is needed at this moment by this child. The mother cannot run to abstract truths. She has to deal with this child, these tears, and this present moment with this child."
Fr. Richard Rohr: Thought for the Day, May 14, 2010

That a mother has to respond to her child to be a good mother, I understand. But why does Fr. Rohr have to pose it in opposition to "theological absolutes"? God can certainly be thought of as a mother - as the Catechism of the Catholic Church indicates - but God is a mother who not only responds in nurture and care, but also in correction and rebuke. As children grow, they go astray and become rebellious. The Israelites in the desert needed nurturance, no doubt, hence the manna and quail and water. But they also needed correction, hence, the seraph serpents and deadly bites. One mother I know just spoke this morning about her three children who need both carrot and stick - and sometimes correction is the more important. And my own experience tells me that I learn at least as much from pain and correction than from affirmation and nurturance.

Maternal love is at once nurturing and stern. It is not either/or.

In the beginning . . .

Today, I start my blog - yippee!

Over and out.

P M